History:

St. Michael's Lutheran Church began life as a mission parish started by the Board of American Missions of the Lutheran Church of America. The first service was held on the 4th of July, 1965, at the Presbyterian Meeting hall in Amagansett.

On the 19th of September, 1965, 35 adults signed the charter of the church, and services were moved to the Amagansett Legion Hall.

Ground was broken for the church structure in July, 1970 and the dedication of the church was held in March 1972.